by Eric Andres | October 30th, 2012
Zach D’Amico has found a home in quidditch in his recent years as he has climbed the ladder to become a respected and educated voice about quidditch. His leadership skills extend to captaining Team USA at the IQA Summer Games, and his experience and knowledge led to an appointment to the IQA Board of Directors.
By Zach D’Amico
Junior Director on the Board
International Quidditch Association
I. Safety Issues in Quidditch
Based on interviews and surveys of current and former quidditch players, spectators, and my
knowledge of the game, I have concluded that the following injuries are what quidditch must
focus most on.
A. Head and Neck injuries
Some of the most common yet most dangerous injuries in quidditch, these must be
prevented. Head injuries consist mostly of concussions, which arise from collisions both
with other players as well as the ground. Neck injuries also come as a result from falls to
the ground, as keeping one hand on the broom (and possibly one with a ball) results in
less ability to break one’s fall.
B. Injured Collarbones and Arms
Another common type of injury in quidditch is the broken or fractured collarbone. Also
partially a result of players never being able to use two hands to break their falls, these
also come from the lack of athletic experience among many quidditch players. Breaking
one’s fall with one arm, especially if that arm is not in the correct position, often results
in an injured collarbone. In addition, having to keep one’s broom-arm stable while
falling can result in a broken arm. While these are not as dangerous or potentially life-
threatening as head and neck injuries, the rate of broken collarbones and arms is far too
high in quidditch.
C. Injured Fingers
Broken fingers and thumbs must not be overlooked, though they appear much less
important than the prior two types of injuries. Quidditch is a unique sport, in that each
player needs all ten fingers working properly. In order to hold a broom, all fingers must
be healthy, and the same goes for a bludger, quaffle, or snitch. Not only does each
player need all extremities working, but because they are used so often, the majority has
had some sort of finger injury ranging from a minor sprain to a break. The major issue
arises because most players don’t see a finger issue as enough reason to stop playing,
and therefore continue to participate. With the constant use of these parts, it is near
impossible for full recovery while still playing. Broken fingers, especially thumbs, that
do not heal properly, can cause serious problems later in life.
D. General Safety
II. Prevention
A. Inform the Community
Informing the community is something that can and should be done as soon as possible.
Most players are not aware of proper technique in falling, tackling, and other safety
protocol.
1. Announcements and Bulletins
The quidditch community is extremely connected today. Using tumblr, facebook, and
the IQA website to put out bulletins regarding safety, basic methods of precaution and
identification of injuries, and other useful tips would help to educate a large amount of
players and enthusiasts.
2. Training Sessions
Training sessions held at colleges and areas with high team density is a great way to help
instruct on proper techniques for safety. These can be taught by experienced athletes and
coaches, whether or not they are involved with quidditch.
B. New Requirements
New requirements and changes in the way the game is played and what is expected of
players would be the most effective way of reducing injuries in quidditch.
1. Injury Identification
From personal experience, as well as talking to others, the worst injuries come when a
player continues to play with a minor or major injury. This can be especially fatal when
concerning head and neck injuries, but nevertheless is the case with all injuries. Whether
a medic or a coach, each team must be required to have a person well-versed in injuries,
and with the authority to keep that player from play.
2. Change in the Rules
Although drastic, player safety is by far the most important thing in quidditch. Any rule
changes deemed necessary to improve player safety must be considered.
III. Safety Panel—who?
A. Football
Football is a full-contact sport just like quidditch. Football has a long history of problems
with concussions, and these players wear pads and helmets whenever playing. Players
and coaches at all levels would be able to provide invaluable insight into safety in
quidditch.
B. Rugby
In terms of general safety, this is the sport most similar to quidditch. It contains similar
levels of contact and similar lack of padding, with the crucial difference of not having a
broomstick.
C. Hockey/Lacrosse
Though very different from quidditch in many ways, both hockey and lacrosse require
their players to handle sticks (just as quidditch does). These are also physical games, and
players must learn how to hit and how to fall while holding onto their sticks. They, as
well as trainers, medics, and coaches, could help both in advising the IQA and training its
players.


Andrew H
October 31, 2012
2:44 pm
I really think that having EMTs on hand at tournaments would be a fantastic requirement as well, just like any other sport. If someone can get medical attention immediately it can make a serious difference.
Adam
October 31, 2012
2:54 pm
As a former player of many of the sports mentioned (as well as others left off), I would very much like to speak with you, especially concerning the new physicality rules and the way that they are enforced. As a player, coach, and fan, I am distressed over the number and severity of injuries I have seen in recent matches. If you get a chance, shoot me an email.
Thank You
Nicholas Wright
October 31, 2012
9:59 pm
What is this article trying to establish? Is it going to be a series in which you update the quidditch community on changes that need to happen within the system that will make the game safer? If so, I am anxious to see the results.
Felicia Walker
November 1, 2012
11:31 am
Agreed with above. It brings up important facts, yes, but does not go into what will actually happen. Ideas and proposals would be nice to read/hear about.
Mark Grabowsky
November 1, 2012
3:54 pm
As a physician and parent of a quidditch player, I have been to both World Cups in NYC. After treating a player with a large cut on her forehead and probably a mild concussion incurred from the rushing to get the balls at the start of the game, I think a rule change should be considered. I note that other sports have changed rules on opening plays to reduce injuries (football: making it easier to kick into endzones, no below the waist blocking; basketball: alternate possession after inital tip-off). Quidditch should consider a similar rule change (e.g., a coin flip and alternate possession).
Kyle Brandenberger
November 2, 2012
12:38 pm
I would also like to weigh in my support of no below the waist blocking. That’s just asking for a ACL or MCL tear.
Kyle Brandenberger
November 2, 2012
12:36 pm
Trained sports med people. You need to look at having someone that can test for cranial nerve injuries and brachial plexus injuries. Based on your comments, these are the two most severe injuries that commonly occur. I would point you to Moore, Dalley, and Agur’s Clinically oriented anatomy.
Shannon Adams
November 8, 2012
4:08 pm
As an Orthopedic Nurse with experience in spine, neck and head injuries, I would very much like to see players trained and educated in the seriousness of these types of insults to still young and growing bodies. Every time I see a quidditch player hit the ground from a tackle I cringe in fear. Quidditch is supposed to be fun. Competition is all well and good, but ITS JUST A GAME.
sceelen
November 12, 2012
7:04 pm
I think we really need to look at what we want out of this sport and start taking Quidditch injuries seriously. After being at my last tournament am starting to see how physically intense this sport can be. I saw 2 concussions happen, and also a women fall to the ground unconscious for a long enough that people could rush over to see her not moving. In another match, I saw a small women (under 130lbs) being blown to the ground in a hard tackle 2 separate times (although legal, most would of questioned the sportsmanship , especially considering such force was not needed to improve a lead of 100 points or more).
Also I began to see that almost every team had a player that was obviously still recovering from serious injury. A woman I met had undergone surgery to fix her shattered tibia and fibula and it cost north of $30,000 to put in all the metal to help set it. (thank god she had insurance)
I am really questioning how much longer I want to play. Most teams are made up of young college kids, but mine is a community team and with that comes a bit more age. I have just learned that these types of injuries don’t seem worth.
Do not get me wrong, I have been to 5 tournaments, I am writing this because I can honestly say this is the best sport I have ever played I just want to see a an expanded dialog, and I hope that we can ask the hard questions to continue to evolve this sport.
Have you seen any serious injuries? Am I over reacting? What do you think?
Stephen
May 12, 2013
2:20 am
At the last world cup I saw one of my best friends from childhood go down with a concussion. It was one of the scariest things I’ve ever seen and concussions are very serious… He did end up being ok btw. But I wouldn’t want to change the game at all. I love the physical side of quidditch. Its a major part of why I play the game. I love the challenge of hitting and being hit. Its a rough sport and I love that. We do need to make sure we have EMTs on hand and we also need to wear reasonable equipment (pads would be so overkill and would actually promote harder hitting… just look at football). One big thing would be teaching people how to hit and be hit, learning how to take a hit is crucial to staying safe in a contact sport. Another thing is this, the rulebook talks about using unnecessary force. While the open endedness of this rule annoys me (it leaves itself far to open to interpretation by a referee), gentleman we need to remember something. There are girls that play this game… and as men we need to do our best to protect them. Do we need to play physically and sometimes lay a hit on a girl? Yes its part of the game, but the amount of force we use to hit them should not be equal to the force we use to hit each other. My point is… if you’re a guy, I’m going to hit as hard as I can to make sure that you go down to the ground, otherwise I’m not doing my job to recover the quaffle for my team. But if you’re a girl, I should be able to do the same thing with a lesser amount of force. Guys, we need to remember that on the pitch.
Regardless of what we do to make the game safer, the only way to stop injuries (including serious injuries like concussions) in quidditch is to remove the hitting aspect of the game and make it a non contact sport. I think most of us would agree, that doing so would be a grave mistake. The game would never be the same. Quidditch is a rough game, each and every one of us assumes the risks involved when we step onto that field. Lets do our best to protect ourselves and others, but lets not dillute the game that we love, or play with any lesser amount of passion because we’re afraid to get hurt or see someone else hurt. If someone doesn’t want to assume the risks… they can always become a fan. Just like hockey, football, or rugby are not for everyone, quidditch is a rough physical contact sport that is not for the faint of heart. That’s part of what makes our game special, its one of the fastest, most intellectually demanding, physical games on the planet…lets keep it that way